Email marketing is not a one-size-fits-all game. Sometimes, the most well-thought-out subject line tanks, while an accidental typo-filled email gets sky-high open rates. Why? Because humans are unpredictable, and sometimes, you just don’t know what works until you test it out. That’s where email A/B testing steps in.
Email A/B testing is the best way to improve email performance by systematically comparing two or more versions of an email to find out what resonates most with your audience. Whether you’re an email newbie or a seasoned pro, perfecting your email testing strategies can make the difference between emails that get deleted and emails that drive results.
What Is Email A/B Testing?
Before diving into strategies, let's start with the basics. Email A/B testing (also known as split testing) is a method where you send two or more variations of an email to your audience to see which performs better. The variables can include anything from subject lines, images, call-to-action buttons (CTAs), to even the length of the email.
But why is it important? Simple. You get actual data on what works best for your audience, instead of making assumptions. This leads to smarter, data-driven decisions and, most importantly, higher engagement.
How Does A/B Testing Improve Email Performance?
Imagine you're hosting a dinner party. You prepare two dishes, but only one becomes the favorite. With A/B testing, you’re essentially figuring out which email “dish” your audience prefers. The result? You’re consistently serving up content that appeals to them, and your open rates, click-through rates, and conversions all start climbing.
Let me drop in some stats. Businesses that regularly perform A/B testing on their email campaigns see an average of 37% higher email open rates. That’s not just a random figure—it’s the real deal. Testing even the smallest aspects of your emails can bring in significant improvements over time.
Email Testing Strategies: What You Should Test
Testing is only as good as the variables you experiment with. If you’re just testing for the sake of testing, well, you’ll end up chasing your own tail. To get started, here are some common elements you should experiment with:
1. Subject Lines
If you’ve ever pondered over a subject line, trying to strike the perfect balance between engaging and clickbaity, you’re not alone. The subject line is the first thing your audience sees, and its impact can’t be understated. A/B testing subject lines can help you figure out if a question, a command, or just plain curiosity is more likely to get your email opened.
For example:
- Version A: “Here’s How to Boost Your Sales in 7 Days”
- Version B: “Want More Sales? Try This”
Which one would you open?
2. Call-to-Action (CTA)
Your email’s CTA is where the rubber meets the road. This is where your audience takes the next step, whether it’s clicking through to your website, downloading a resource, or signing up for a webinar. Experiment with different CTAs to see which wording, button color, or placement works best.
Try testing:
- Button color (red vs. blue)
- CTA placement (top of the email vs. bottom)
- Language (actionable words like “Get Started Now” vs. softer prompts like “Learn More”)
3. Email Design
Some say less is more, while others prefer a rich visual layout. This is a matter of taste, and A/B testing can help you figure out what design style your audience responds to. Do they prefer a text-heavy email, or do images and infographics grab their attention more? Balance between visual elements and text is key here.
4. Sending Time
When you send your emails is almost as important as what’s in them. Some audiences are more responsive in the morning, while others are more likely to engage in the late afternoon. A/B test different send times and days of the week to discover when your audience is most likely to engage with your content.
5. Personalization
Adding a personal touch to your emails can make all the difference. A/B test the inclusion of personalization tokens like the recipient's first name in the subject line or body. However, don't overdo it. Too much personalization can sometimes come off as trying too hard. It’s all about finding that sweet spot.
The Do’s and Don’ts of Email A/B Testing
Now that you’re pumped to start testing, here are a few ground rules:
Do: Test One Variable at a Time
The temptation to test everything at once is real, but resist it. If you change too many variables, you won’t know what led to the change in performance. Pick one element, like the subject line or CTA, and test that.
Don’t: Forget About Sample Size
Running an A/B test on 10 email subscribers will not give you the data you need. Make sure your test sample is large enough to provide statistically significant results. A general rule is to have at least 1,000 subscribers in your test group for reliable data.
Do: Test Regularly
One-and-done is not the way to go. Email trends change, and what worked last month might not work today. Regular testing ensures that you’re always on top of what your audience wants.
Don’t: Assume Results Will Be Instant
Some tests might show immediate results, but others will require time. Be patient and give your test enough time to gather substantial data.
Tools for A/B Testing Your Emails
Using the right tool is half the battle. And while there are many platforms out there, there’s something to be said for simplicity and functionality. If you’re looking for a platform that not only makes A/B testing intuitive but also provides all the advanced features you need without burying you in complexity, Tarvent is your go-to.
At Tarvent, we make it incredibly easy to run tests without needing a PhD in statistics. With our platform, you’ll have access to comprehensive analytics that let you see the results of your tests in real-time, so you can continuously optimize your campaigns. Plus, our support team is always ready to jump in—whether by phone, text, or (no joke) even smoke signals—to help you figure out your next move.
Conclusion
Email A/B testing is not just a nice-to-have. It’s a must-do for anyone serious about improving their email marketing results. With regular testing, you can ensure your campaigns are constantly evolving and hitting the mark with your audience. Remember, even small tweaks can lead to major improvements over time. Start simple, track your progress, and always keep experimenting.
TL;DR
A/B testing is a data-driven method to improve email performance by testing variables like subject lines, CTAs, and email design. By running regular tests and focusing on one variable at a time, you can optimize your email campaigns for better engagement and conversions. Tarvent simplifies A/B testing with an intuitive platform, offering expert support whenever you need it.
%201.svg)
